How to Give Feedback Other Writers Actually Want

How to Give Feedback Other Writers Actually Want

Every writer on Parchment started somewhere, usually with a first story they were nervous to share. The responses they received shaped whether they kept going. That is why we care so much about how our community talks to each other.

Good feedback is one of the most generous things you can give another writer. Here is how to make yours count.

Read the whole story first

It sounds obvious, but many comments respond to a headline or a single line. Read to the end before you reply. Understand what the writer was trying to do before you judge whether they did it.

Start with what works

Tell the writer what landed for you, and be specific. "Great post" is kind but tells them nothing. "The story about your first client made the whole point click for me" tells them what to do more of.

Be specific about what could be better

Vague criticism is hard to act on. Point to a place in the story and describe your experience as a reader.

  • Instead of "This is confusing," try "I lost the thread in the third section when the example changed."
  • Instead of "Too long," try "The opening took a while to reach the main idea for me."

Describing your reaction is more useful, and easier to hear, than issuing a verdict.

Focus on the writing, not the writer

Comment on choices in the text, never on the person. Disagreeing with an idea is welcome on Parchment. Attacking the person who shared it is not, and it goes against our community guidelines.

Offer one or two suggestions, not ten

A long list of corrections can feel overwhelming, even when every point is fair. Choose the one or two changes that would make the biggest difference and leave the rest.

Respect what the writer asked for

If a writer asks for thoughts on structure, do not spend your comment on grammar. If they share something personal, respond with care before critique. Sometimes the most useful response is simply to say that the story mattered to you.

A simple pattern to follow

  1. One specific thing that worked.
  2. One specific thing that could be stronger, and why.
  3. One sentence of encouragement.

It takes a minute, and it might be the reason someone writes their second story.

Receiving feedback well

If you are on the other side, thank people for their time, take what is useful and let the rest go. You do not have to accept every suggestion. You only have to listen.

Parchment Community

Written by

Join the conversation

More from Parchment